Showing posts with label Caol Ila. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Caol Ila. Show all posts

Sunday, July 1, 2018

Artists and their whiskies

Bought this at a LMDW sale earlier this year. Let's see...

Image result for Caol ila lmdw artist
Image from whiskybase



Caol Ila, LMDW Artist Collective, 6 years (abv 43%)

Colour - pale, pale gold.

Nose - Butterscotch, lemon custard. Peat, algae, salt. This is pretty classic Caol Ila. There's notes of fish on this too. Grassy, with almost a floral note. The maritime note grows too, almost like oysters.

Palate - Smoke and charcoal. Salty and buttery. I like salted butter, by the way. None of that tame margarine thingy. Pity that's the only one at home now...for health reasons, of course. There's a growing lemon edge, reminding you that it's Caol Ila. A little bubblegum too. Some bitter fruit peel on the way down...and a bit of a meaty side. Elusive, but I think it's there.

Finish - more of that smoke. I imagine like a cigar. Spiciness grows in the finish, more so than on the palate. There's a bit of oak and bitterness.

Overall - This is good Caol Ila. Is it special? Different? I think it's not unexpected from Caol Ila, which is good if you like a Caol Ila to be like Caol Ila, but maybe nothing special for an Indie bottler. Maybe sweeter and meatier, but otherwise, fairly standard Caol Ila.

The partnership between artists and whisky makers is pretty interesting. I think that people who work a craft have so much in common - dedication to tradition, innovators finding their own voice. Something from a bygone era finding new relevance today...I've a bottle of Glentauchers that was bottled as a commemorative for an Art Museum. Let's see...maybe next month...

Monday, December 18, 2017

Don't Caol Ila chickens before they hatch...

I missed this year's Whisky Live as I had to bring kids overseas. This was what PY bought on my behalf, after strong recommendation from the LMdW staff. He bought for himself an Ardmore 9 years from the same series, but I think the informal tasting I had of it isn't good enough for note publishing. Maybe next time!

This continues my quest for peat in the lead up to Christmas in sunny Singapore, where there are no fireplaces to sit around sipping Lagavulin, so I'll have to make do.

Caol Ila 6 years, Artists' Collective by LMdW (abv 43%)


Colour - Very pale

Nose - Cucumber, zucchini, honey dew, pears. That's all the green stuff coming out straight at me. Strong malty backing. Brioche moistened by wet scrambled eggs. This is a good, balanced breakfast, completed with some jasmine tea notes. Then breakfast ends, with smoke from burning incense. An odd lingering scent of shaven oak. This one stands out if you look for it. Maybe the cask is a little active?

Palate - Oysters, salt. Lemon. Oily without too much viscosity. A touch of smoked ham. Lots of spices - pepper, lots of ginger. Seaweed. A nutty middle, almost like praline. Hazelnut syrup. The sap from a cut ladies' finger/okra. This is a little odd; didn't pick it up the first time round at PY's place. Smokey, without being overbearing.

Finish - Charred oak and lemon juice. Pepper and cloves. The skin of a roasted almond. This roasted almond stays with you for a really long time.

Overall - This is very green, and very good. Clean but complex, apart from the slightly off-putting okra sap. Odd. The bottle alone is worth some money, if you intend to collect this as part of a set. Alas, LMdW Singapore has already run out of most of the bottles in this collective.

That bottle arts looks like some flower illuminati, but I guess it could also mean that all colours converge on one flower (what?)


Monday, September 25, 2017

Indie Caol Ila

Just as Man U is currently stringing together a good sequence of wins, I'm going to do a sequence of peaty whiskies from everyone's favourite Scotch region. A couple of the whiskies in this sequence are very kindly shared by friends - thanks PY and NF (in advance)! As promised in the previous, this one is a strong Caol Ila.



PY bought this indie Caol Ila some time back at LMDW, and we had a quick sip. His initial review was that this Caol Ila is the real thing, making a Kilchoman single sherry cask feel 'feignty'. Big bold claim. He kindly gave me a small sample to try at leisure, and I'm finally giving this a shot.

Caol Ila G&M 'Cask Strengh', 2004/2015 (60.1% abv)

Nose - Sharp attack, like Lukaku - big alcohol tendrils unfurling in your nose. Wasabi-like. A hint of kerosene and flint - explosive, like Rashford's pace. Behind that, smoke and lemons, then salt. Pears, pear rind, a little vanilla, and some rich notes from the cask, I believe - oak, a touch of coconut, peach. Peat turns ashy from the rather grassier initial profile. Complex and intricate, like Mkhitaryan. Ok, enough Man United references...

Palate - Lemonade! Vanilla and honey. Nectar. Toffee. Lots of sweet stuff going on here! Help! I think I'm losing the war on diabetes! Oh, great, there's the chalk and salt to the rescue! Some bitter notes, like tea. Pear drops, stewed fruit. Smoke and ashes. A big beach bonfire. Grapefruit and ginger, then a bunch of pepper sprinkled with clove and...parsley? Tea tannin...overbrewed Chinese tea.

Finish - Charcoal smoke, like sitting beside the campfire after the flames die down. Lots of pepper, some chalk, a hint of nut oils, lingering ginger. A little bitter for my liking though.

Overall - wow. That was intense. I wouldn't say that this makes the Kilchoman feel feinty, for I think the Kilchoman's a little more polished than this Caol Ila. Nonetheless, this IS very big and intense, like Matic's pres...ok, never mind. How does G&M get their hands on so many barrels of such good stock?

Great start to the Islay sequence! Up next is...NF's PC!

Monday, September 4, 2017

Caol Ila for newbies

This bottle is from LMDW's The Ten series. The series is meant to be an introduction to the various prominent styles of whiskies from Scotland, and thus are labelled things like 'Heavy Smoke', 'Intermediate Sherry' (oh wait, was that for Amrut?), 'Light sherry', etc. This one is 'Medium Islay Peat'. The whisky is from Caol Ila, distilled in 2008 and bottled in 2015, making it 7 years. I think it's a marketing strategy for the seventh whisky in the Ten to also be seven years. So, one number, two interpretations, both valid. Yay. A hermeneuticist's best friend.

Caol Ila 'The Ten' for LMDW (abv 40.10%)
Image result for LMDW the ten medium islay peat

Colour - Pale. Very pale. Paler than the picture suggests. The pee of a normal person who's maybe a little dehydrated.

Nose - Light Islay peat, contrary to what the label claims. This is lighter than usual Caol Ilas. Smokey without venturing into the heavily charred territory of Ardbeg. Not even the pure charcoal smoke of Caol Ila. This is more like lightly charred wood. The light smoke helps one to notice the other aspects of Caol Ila - citrusy. Suggestions of apricots. A little savoury, with a generous dash of salt.

Palate - Mm. Alcohol heat, probably due to age. But fairly fruity. Pears and apples, with a hint of grapefruit. Orange pith. Ooh. Surprising sweet touch...tastes a bit like triple-sec. Pepper. Salty too.

Finish - A little minty and maybe one eucalyptus leaf. Peppery, a whiff of smoke that wasn't prominent on the palate comes back up the chimney.

Overall - As an introductory malt, this is actually pretty tasty, and showcases the goodness of a simple, naked Caol Ila. Not complex enough to wow, but good to use as part of an educational tasting set. Though I would probably tell tasters that this is not 'Medium', but light. And, perhaps the peat isn't as obvious here, though perhaps a comparison with, say, a light Laphroaig might help the newcomer to recognize peat. I'm also wondering if the ".10%" abv is part of the branding. Probably, right?

Next post will be a heavy Caol Ila. 

Sunday, July 3, 2016

Regions of Scotland Part 2 (and I have made a terrible mistake)

On to Islay and the Lowlands next!

Caol Ila 2006/2015 "Whisky of the Year" (abv. 52.9, for the Auld Alliance)


This one is a bit of a joke made by the guys at the Auld Alliance, targeted at how some whisky competitions award prizes to whiskies based on very narrow categories. In this case, the Auld Alliance awarded this "Whisky of the Year" in the category for Caol Ila 2006-2015, 52.9% for the Auld Alliance. Creative eh?

To side-track a little, this is what seems to be happening to how prizes are awarded. Create ever more specific categories, recognize whiskies for being the best in the world according to a very narrow definition, and let everyone raise their prices because they're "award-winning whiskies". It seems like prizes are given out to as many people as possible, instead of letting genuine, fair competition happen. Which, unfortunately, seems to be how some educators try to motivate their students. Unfortunately, when everyone is special in his own special way, the word "special" loses its meaning. But I digress.

Nose - This is very meaty, a real BBQ party. I think there's beef on the grill, as well as some smoked ham. The peat is very much in the forefront, though it's smoky as well. Definitely not a "light" Islay, this Caol Ila. The age and abv tells too, as the alcohol and brightness of the aromas testify. Behind the peat and smoke is a solid layer of citrus fruits - lemon, grapefruit. And then further behind that, a nice grassy profile to hold the nose together. Spicy too! Just a light touch of vanilla, but maybe I'm imagining things. This is well layered and complex, especially after accounting for its age.

Palate - peat and smoke is rather big on entry, but that is quickly taken over by big sour notes. Lemons, I think. Freshly cut and bursting with lemony flavours. Spicy in a up-your-nose way. So that'll make it wasabi? Freshly ground wasabi at that - green, grassy undertones behind the spicy kick. A little..."dusty", like an old book. After a while, this gets a little malty, but overall, fairly well-balanced.

Finish - Mmm. Long...lemon/orange zest, slight bitterness, but overall, the sours keeps the whole finish fresh. Which is quite an accomplishment, considering the strength of the smoke.

Overall - DW and JE preferred the Kilchoman Machir Bay, which they only ordered because I was hard-selling it, and joking that we should buy a stake in the distillery. The Machir Bay has a cleaner taste profile - less...chalky/grassy/dusty, not as big on sours, sweeter, and a more precise smoke that's not as peaty as the Caol Ila. I personally like this Caol Ila just fine. The Machir Bay's better for sipping, but this is good too.

Lastly, the Lowlander!

(Ok, major mistake. Dalwhinnie is, of course, not a lowlander, but a highlander. So, with Campbeltown, Speyside and Lowlands missing, these 2 most recent posts can't be called "Regions of Scotland" anymore, can it? Meh. Shall not edit this so that I will always have evidence of shoddy work to spur myself on. It even says "highland" on the label, for crying out loud. Bad. Really bad.)

Dalwhinnie Distiller's Edition 1995/2011 (abv 43%)


We ordered this last. Unfortunately, it was the least liked of the 5 we had on the night.

Nose - Floral and perfumed. Oaky and some liquorice notes. Hmm. It's inoffensive, I guess.

Palate - The additional maturation period imparted a bit of leather. Hmm. Maybe a very small raisin. Fairly...sweet...hmm. What kind of sweetness though? Not honey...Maybe a liquorice-based sweet, which I am not exactly fond of. Fairly perfumed and lightly floral, but I won't say its pleasant enough to be in the same class as, say, Hibiki 12. 

Finish - Mmm. Sweet-ish, closer to oak than sherry. Maybe a touch of heather, but the finish is predominantly oak. Light leather, so it's a bit drying. Slightly porridgy too. 

Overall - Maybe I was tired by the time I got to this, but I'm not sure I like this.

Ok, I'm demotivated by my big boo-boo. Goodnight! Shall have to make up for it with a real Lowlander, and a Campbeltown next time.

Wednesday, May 11, 2016

Quick sip of the Gordon and Macphail Connoisseur's Choice Caol Ila 2001 - 2014

A quick sip of the Caol Ila from the same series as the previous Ledaig. Roughly the same age too. Thanks to PY for this!

Gordon and Macphail Connoisseur's Choice Caol Ila 2001 - 2014

Nose - A little meaty, but not as big as in the Ledaig. That one was a cured meat market. This one feels more like the smell of ham lingering on the plate after the ham's been eaten. Fruity - apple peel, pear peel. Not quite the fruit itself though. This is "greener". A touch of vanilla and coconut - was this matured in a refill bourbon cask? Peat is not very strong in this, but rather smoky. Seems fairly characteristic of a Caol Ila, but perhaps with a bit more intensity. This vintage is better than the OB 12 year old.

Palate - This is smooth. Doesn't have much of an alcohol bite, and it is fairly velvety in texture. A fair amount of pepper, but the pepper doesn't hit hard. More like a low flame than a big blaze. The smoke is assertive, without extinguishing the fruitiness. Again, some apple peel, pear peel, and maybe a bit of coconut, but I'm not sure. Feels like a creamy smoked fruit. Does such a thing exist? Has anyone had smoked durians...? There's some savoury meatiness in there too, which makes it harder to distinguish the fruit. Maybe a guava with a bit of plum salt? The kind that you get at Singapore fruit stalls. Speaking of guava with salt, the best one I've ever tasted was from Taiwan, at the Huayuan Night Market at Tainan.

Finish - The pepper goes out with one last hurrah, leaving a tingling spiciness in its wake. This one lasts long. I had to put out the pepper with water to get a second taste.Anything else on the finish? Hmm. Faint smokiness, pepper...I don't think any of the fruits survived the last pepper blast.

Overall: The Ledaig was more fun and whacky, but this is classier. A good dram that showcases classic Caol Ila, but turns it up a notch. Good for its age! And, considering that PY got this at the same sale where I got the Ledaig, very value for money.