Thursday, January 5, 2017

2017's first notch - Benromach 10

Happy new year! The year end passed by in a flurry of activity and gatherings. Not many whisky parties, and hardly any new drinks to show for it. Except this one: the Benromach 10.


We were supposed to try DW's 30 year old Port Ellen, but the cork broke, and we didn't have the tools to dig out the cork, or to decant the bottle, at that point in time. He's now decanted the Port Ellen, so, let's hope we manage to get down to it soon. So disappointing though. I guess I'm really not fated to try this one.

I brought the Benromach 10 to the party, more as an aperitif, or starter. But instead, it became a poor substitute for the main striker who limped off injured in the warm-up. Benromach 10 is a solid player, mind. Just not star quality.

Benromach 10 (43% abv)

Colour - Gold

Nose - Pencil wood, oak, then soft sherry notes - that'll be dried fruits like raisins and cranberries. Some herbal, leafy notes too, though these aren't too distinct. Lightly smoky, though it smells more like smouldering leaves than a proper wood fire. A little smouldering damp leaves. There's something savoury at the back too, though I'm not really managing to pick it out.

Palate - Gentle landing, you hardly feel any alcohol. Fairly sweet. That'll be some caramelized sugar and sherry. A slight tanginess that reminds me of mustard. More leaves and oak - the oak's rather big, and gives the sherry a bit more of a vanilla and oaky balance. More pencil shavings. Mouth feel is oily, and there's also something that reminds me of cod liver oil. Hmm. But on the whole, oak and sweetness would be the main stuff. The wood helps to prevent this whisky from being too one dimensional, and it is solid. But it's also clearly young due to relatively short development. To be fair, I didn't try this with water. Maybe it'll get better.

Finish - Oaky again, light whiff of smoke, a leeeeeettle bit of spice. Some tea tannins here, and a bit drying.

Overall - solid, value for money, but not the bang to start the year I was hoping for.

Saturday, December 24, 2016

Talisker 25 on 25 December



After some delay, I'm finally getting down to write about this. This is, to date, the most expensive bottle I've paid for with my own money. Talisker is among my top 3 favourite distilleries, though its NAS bottlings don't quite live up to the legacy of the name. The Port Ruighe was nice enough, as was Dark Storm, but nothing that screams Talisker, like the 10 or 18. And now, this - the Talisker 25 from a bygone era.

Nothing screams Christmas like a peaty, smoky, peppery, spicy dram of whisky, even if you are living in sunny Singapore, right?

Talisker 25 Year Old / Bot.2007
Image from the Whisky Exchange

Talisker used to bottle the 25 year old and the 30 year old at cask strength. Not single cask, just cask strength. This one's bottled at 58.1% abv. That's several notches above the standard 45.8% that Talisker bottles things at nowadays. The upside is that you can now get the Talisker 25 as a regular bottling. The downside is that you'll probably not hit the same highs that the older bottlings were able to achieve. 

This bottle is a mix of various cask types, with some sherry influence on top of the usual refill and bourbon casks. At 58.1%, I'm guessing that this will need some water, but let's do it neat first.

Talisker 25, bottled 2007 (58.1%)

Colour - Well, the bottle is slightly tinted, so the liquid isn't as dark as it might appear to be. Gold, instead of something approaching amber.

Nose - This is intense. Big pepper, sea spray. Let my nose get used to it a little, and more subtle notes appear - honey, really. Light peat and smoke, with suggestions of red fruit. There seems to be a bit of vanilla, and toffee too. Sea salt taffy, perhaps. Fairly oaky undertones, that help to hold the rest of the nose together. What I enjoyed most about this nose is its intensity - the big pepper and sea salt don't go away. It stays and powers through the nose. The other scents come out subtly against the pepper and sea, but the intensity of the usual Talisker profile doesn't become more muted - your nose just gets used to it. The gripping pepper and salt are on one pole, and the gentle oak on the other, gives this Talisker 25 a nose that develops in depth, with different tones appearing the more you nose it, yet staying within the boundaries created by the space between Talisker's wild side and the calming influence of the wood.

Palate - It's like you chewed some black peppercorns, with some red peppers thrown in. It's unmistakably Talisker. The intensity of the pepper really strikes you, just like on the nose. With some time on the tongue, you get...honey, some vanilla, almost bourbon-y sweetness, which adds to the smoothness of this dram, despite the high strength. There's cloves and maybe a touch of something bitter and citrusy, like parsley or coriander. Maybe lemon zest. Butterscotch, or maybe that's just the salt, vanilla and honey coming together. What I probably mean is that this is sweet, savoury and smooth, at the same time. There's smoke and light peat - the smoke is fairly clean, like an unsooty charcoal flame, and the peat is light. Not sure what they burn there on Talisker. I really should visit someday.

Finish - Mmm. The pepper lasts the longest. Cloves and nutmeg spiced finish, which is probably the influence of the sherry cask. Slightly peaty, a little bitter, and a fair whack of oak and wood tannins. Then there's pepper again. A hint of sweetness to round off. 

Ok, that was great, but maybe a little too intense. Let's see what water does to it.

With water - about 5 drops to the dram

Nose - this is immediately more gentle, more open, but still distinctly Talisker. The pepper takes a bit more of a backseat, allowing the oak and honey sweetness to come to the front. There's more fruit too - I'm getting some figs and dried cherries. So...sweet, red, and slightly sour at the same time. Unless the dried cherries I've had are spoilt. Hope not. A little hint of nuttiness - or was that just a different tone to the wood? Same ballpark as having it neat, but slightly more nuanced and round, less brutal on the pepper spray

Palate - Butterscotch, definitely butterscotch. Butterscotch, honey, vanilla, and ripe fruits - I'm thinking of something yellow, like syrup soaked pineapple, or nearly overripe mangoes. Maybe rock melon. But water doesn't water down the intensity, simply drags out other flavours into prominence, without really drowning the kick that the pepper gives. In this case, the pepper has its say later. This is richer than the Talisker 18, definitely.

Finish - shorter, but same profile. Though I think the pepper feels more heaty here.

Overall - I'm impressed and very satisfied. DW says this is not as good as the Kilchoman 2008 vintage - I obviously disagree. I don't think the Kilchoman hits this level of intensity on the pepper, nor the richness of the liquid. But then, the Kilchoman is a about 1/3 the age. And 1/4 the price. Maybe Kilchoman is more value for money, and maybe it'll age better. Who knows? In any case, the Talisker 25 is great stuff, and a style of whisky that made many whisky fans fall in love with the spirit in the first place - intense and rich, smooth and fiery, peppery and sweet. The power of the spirit really stands out here, despite the 25 years in wood. 

And with that, merry Christmas! God is with us! And if you need an artificial fire to add to the mood...


Monday, December 19, 2016

Norse Gods and Kings

Recently read The Gospel of Loki, by Joanne Harris. It's fairly fun, and retells the main storyline of the Norse gods from Loki's perspective. This Loki is rather perceptive and self-aware, with recognition of his own role in why he came to be known as the trickster, and the role he plays in bringing on Ragnarok, or, the Norse version of the end times.



The premise is a fairly interesting twist, and it helps when you can imagine Hiddleston as the protagonist in the story. What grates, unfortunately, is the writing style. Loki, the narrator, seems to speak like a slimy American businessman, or someone running for President. The slyness comes out in bits and pieces, and half the time, he's just out to have fun. What I felt was missing was the bit of malice behind the tricks, and the sense of chaos. While Loki represents chaos in the story world, he doesn't really upset the apple cart much, and doesn't do much to reverse power relations either. Loki ends up being a little too rational and, well, normal. I dunno. Maybe I'm missing the point through my unfamiliarity with Norse legends, but the book's style and characterization of Loki left me wondering if the Trickster could be amped up a little bit more.

Which, coincidentally, is what I think about the whisky I'm writing about today: Highland Park's Harald, released for the Travail Travel Retail market. Harald is part of a series of other whiskies named after Viking/Norse warriors of old. Those cheaper than Harald were sold in 1 litre bottles, while Harald and above were sold in the standard 700ml bottles. Which perhaps suggests that Harald is about where things start to get serious. Unfortunately, I think Harald doesn't get serious enough, which is a shame. King Harald sounds like a pretty badass.



Highland Park Harald (40% abv)

Colour - Gold

Nose - Pretty nice, really. Classic Highland Park with sherry and smoke. The sherry comes across in raisins and the spices you usually associate with sherried whiskies - cinnamon, cloves, nutmeg. Honey, and fairly obvious orange notes, I thought. With a bit of time, there's a faint floral note as well as some light peat instead of smoke. This is balanced, and pretty characteristic of Highland Park.

Palate - Oranges and cinnamon apple dessert. Sweet, with smoke. Honey remains. The smoke is pretty nicely balanced against the sherry influence. Spices remain, but not as strong as it felt on the nose. Mouth feel is a little...watery, despite the heavier flavours. I guess this was chill-filtered? Lacking a little fatness and minerality that would have added more edge to this rounded whisky. Balance and round, but I think it lacks a little depth. Everything is there on the palate on first tasting, without the development of chocolate, tea, or whatever else that I got from the HP 18. A little drying.

Finish - Short-ish, unlike the reign of King Harald. Spicy (more reminiscent of ginger now), oaky dryness. Mm. Lingering smoke and some caramelized apples.

Overall - This is easy and pleasant drinking! Smooth with little burn. Good balance of flavours between the various classic Highland Park flavours. However, this doesn't quite live up to the Warrior billing. Many reviewers of the series have noted this, and I share their opinion, that if you're going to name your whiskies after kings and warriors, could you make your whiskies a little stronger? Perhaps 46% abv? And un-chill filtered would be good too, to give the whisky a little more fat to survive the cold seas. Maybe a stronger concentration would help the whisky display more depth, but alas, it's easier to add water than to take it out.

So, good, but not quite strong enough, both for the book, and the whisky. Hard to live up to the Norse legends of old eh?